Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box

Welcome to the Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box—your curated collection for turning premium spices into unforgettable meals. A Fort Collins staple for over a decade, we’re here to help you master the art of flavor in your own kitchen.

Browse recipes by category

Finding matches...

    Recipes

    Close-up of a Banana Split cupcake with a Chocolate Whipped Cream Frosting

    Banana Split Cupcakes with Chocolate Whipped Cream

    Turn a simple yellow box cake mix into a gourmet bakery masterpiece! These easy Banana Split Cupcakes feature a quick banana-cherry swirl base, rich homemade...

    Alex
    Close-up of a Root Beer Float cupcake with a vanilla bean frosting

    Easy Root Beer Float Cupcakes with Vanilla Bean Buttercream Frosting

    Bring the soda fountain home with these Root Beer Float Cupcakes! A spicy, sassafras-infused cake topped with rich vanilla bean buttercream—the perfect nostalgic treat for...

    Alex
    Chinese Five Spice Cake

    Chinese Five Spice Cake

    Experience the bold flavors of our Chinese Five Spice & Orange Cake, a unique snacking cake featuring an ultra-moist, custard-like crumb made with eight egg...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Vanilla Extract

    Vanilla Extract

    Elevate your baking with this guide to making homemade vanilla extract. Learn how to create a rich, high-quality essence from scratch to enhance everything from...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Spicy Snickerdoodles

    Spicy Snickerdoodles

    Add a fiery twist to a classic with this Spicy Snickerdoodle recipe. Learn how to balance a soft, chewy cinnamon-sugar base with the unexpected heat...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Soft Gingerbread Cookies

    Soft Gingerbread Cookies

    How to make Soft Gingerbread Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Pumpkin Spice Dip

    Pumpkin Spice Dip

    How to make Pumpkin Spice Dip Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Pumpkin Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookies

    Pumpkin Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookies

    How to make Pumpkin Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Italian Christmas Cookies

    Italian Christmas Cookies

    How to make Italian Christmas Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Ginger & Molasses Cookies

    Ginger & Molasses Cookies

    How to make Ginger & Molasses Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Spiced Orange Cookies

    Spiced Orange Cookies

    How to make Spiced Orange Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Chocolate Grasshopper Ice Cream Tart

    Chocolate Grasshopper Ice Cream Tart

    How to make Chocolate Grasshopper Ice Cream Tart Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Apple and Cubeb Oatmeal Cookies

    Apple and Cubeb Oatmeal Cookies

    How to make Apple and Cubeb Oatmeal Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    No-Bake Lemon-Lavender Cheesecake

    No-Bake Lemon-Lavender Cheesecake

    How to make No-Bake Lemon-Lavender Cheesecake Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Sparkly Sugar Cookies

    Sparkly Sugar Cookies

    How to make Sparkly Sugar Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Cardamom Rose

    Cardamom Rose "Persian Love" Cookies

    How to make Cardamom Rose "Persian Love" Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Spicy Mexican Chocolate Chip Cookies

    Spicy Mexican Chocolate Chip Cookies | Sweet & Heat Gourmet Cookie Recipe

    How to make Spicy Mexican Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    Orange Cardamom Snickerdoodle Cookies

    Orange Cardamom Snickerdoodle Cookies – Soft, Chewy & Aromatic Spiced Treats

    How to make Orange Cardamom Snickerdoodle Cookies Recipe ...

    Old Town Spice Shop Recipe Box
    1 2