Cart (0)

Your cart is currently empty.
Return to shop

This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

  • About Us
  • Products
  • Gift Boxes
  • Wholesale
  • Recipes & More
    • Recipes
    • Blog
  • Log in
Old Town Spice Shop
  • About Us
  • Products
  • Gift Boxes
  • Wholesale
  • Recipes & More
    • Recipes
    • Blog
  • 0
Old Town Spice Shop
Search 0 Cart
Home / Shop / Top Selling

Top Selling

Award-winning dry rubs and smoky blends perfect for brisket, ribs, and backyard burgers.

BBQ Rubs & Grilling Seasonings

Zesty, authentic blends to upgrade your taco nights, fajitas, and homemade chili.

Taco & Mexican Seasonings

Instant party favorites—simply mix these savory spices with sour cream, yogurt, or avocado.

Dip Mixes & Party Appetizers

Big, bold flavor without the sodium. Perfect for heart-healthy diets and pure spice lovers.

Salt-Free & Health Blends

Take your tastebuds on a trip with our Italian herbs, spicy Cajun blends, and aromatic curries.

World Flavor: Curry, Cajun & More

Premium cinnamons, infused sugars, and rich cocoas to make your desserts unforgettable.

Baking Spices & Sweet Blends

Clear all
loading...
Clear all
loading...
Lemon Peel
Lemon Peel
View options
Lemon Peel
From Regular price $6.90
From $6.90
Jar of anise seed with Old Town Spice Shop label next to a pile of anise seeds.
Jar of dried anise seeds with a black lid on a white background
View options
Anise Seed, Whole
From Regular price $6.90
From $6.90
Jar of ground fenugreek seed with a visible label on a light blue background
Spice jar with black lid on a white background
View options
Fenugreek Seed, Ground
From Regular price $5.90
From $5.90
Harbinger Coffee Rub
Harbinger Coffee Rub
Sold out
Harbinger Coffee Rub
Regular price $9.90
$9.90
Butcher Cut Black Peppercorn container from Old Town Spice Shop on a white plate with peppercorns.
Spice jar with black lid on a white background
View options
Black Peppercorn, Butcher Cut
From Regular price $6.90
From $6.90
(5.0)
Lemon Juice Powder
Lemon Juice Powder
View options
Lemon Juice Powder
From Regular price $5.90
From $5.90
South Carolina Barbecue - Regional BBQ Seasonings
South Carolina Barbecue - Regional BBQ Seasonings
View options
South Carolina Barbecue - Regional BBQ Seasonings
From Regular price $6.90
From $6.90
Citrus Balance Oil Dip
Citrus Balance Oil Dip
View options
Citrus Balance Oil Dip
From Regular price $7.90
From $7.90
Cardamom Seed, Whole
Cardamom Seed, Whole
View options
Cardamom Seed, Whole
From Regular price $7.90
From $7.90
Bottle of Auntie Stone Beer Mustard with a sandwich and beer mug in the background
Spice jar with label on a white background
Auntie Stone Beer Mustard
Regular price $8.00
$8.00
Pure Tahitian Vanilla Extract
Pure Tahitian Vanilla Extract
View options
Pure Tahitian Vanilla Extract
From Regular price $23.00
From $23.00
Old Town Chai Tea Latte - Golden Chai
Old Town Chai Tea Latte - Golden Chai
View options
Old Town Chai Tea Latte - Golden Chai
From Regular price $5.50
From $5.50
(5.0)
Grains of Paradise
Grains of Paradise
View options
Grains of Paradise
From Regular price $7.20
From $7.20
Asafoetida Powder
Asafoetida Powder
View options
Asafoetida Powder
From Regular price $7.50
From $7.50
Epazote Powder
Epazote Powder
View options
Epazote Powder
From Regular price $5.90
From $5.90
Jar of Old Town Spice Shop Lemongrass Powder with a pile of powder in the background.
Spice jar with a black lid and white label on a white background
View options
Lemongrass Powder
From Regular price $4.90
From $4.90
Achiote Seasoning
Spice jar with a label on a white background
View options
Achiote Seasoning
From Regular price $6.90
From $6.90
Furikake Seasoning
Furikake Seasoning
View options
Furikake Seasoning
From Regular price $9.90
From $9.90
(4.0)
Cinchona Bark
Cinchona Bark
View options
Cinchona Bark
From Regular price $6.20
From $6.20
(5.0)
Spice jar labeled 'Down Home Pickle Shake' from Old Town Spice Shop with a white background
Jar of Old Town Spice Shop Down Home Pickle Shake seasoning with a label.
View options
Down Home Pickle Seasoning
From Regular price $7.90
From $7.90
(5.0)
Beer cheese pub dip with soft pretzels
Beer Cheese Pub Dip Mix
View options
Beer Cheese Pub Dip Mix
From Regular price $7.90
From $7.90
Tea Lovers Sampler Gift Box
Tea Lovers Sampler Gift Box
Tea Lovers Sampler Gift Box
Regular price $20.00
$20.00
Cornflower Petals
Cornflower Petals
View options
Cornflower Petals
From Regular price $6.90
From $6.90
Jalapeno powder jar from Old Town Spice Shop on a bed of ground pepper.
Jalapeno powder jar from The Spice Shop on a white background
View options
Jalapeno Chile Powder
From Regular price $8.90
From $8.90
Fenugreek Seed, Whole
Fenugreek Seed, Whole
View options
Fenugreek Seed, Whole
From Regular price $4.90
From $4.90
Rose Hips
Rose Hips
View options
Rose Hips
From Regular price $5.50
From $5.50
Redmond Utah Salt
Redmond Utah Salt
View options
Redmond Utah Salt
From Regular price $6.90
From $6.90
Onion Salt
Onion Salt
View options
Onion Salt
From Regular price $5.90
From $5.90
Golden marigold sugar for baking
Marigold Sugar
View options
Marigold Sugar
From Regular price $7.90
From $7.90
Angelica Root
Angelica Root
View options
Angelica Root
From Regular price $3.90
From $3.90
  • 1
  • …
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • …
  • 24

Join our Mailing List

Subscribe to our newsletter to get recipes, new product alerts, and more directly to your inbox.

Quick links
  • Home
  • About
  • Gift Boxes
  • Corporate Gifts
  • Products
  • Wholesale
  • Contact Us
Resources
  • FAQs
  • Return Policy
  • Shipping Policy
  • Refund Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
Visit Our Store:

130A S. College Ave.,
Fort Collins, CO 80524

(970) 493-7206

Hours: 
Mon - Sat 10am to 6pm
Sundays 11am to 5pm

Production Facility: (Closed to the public)

1833 E Harmony Rd, Unit 1B Fort Collins, CO 80528

Follow us
  • Australia (AUD $)
  • Canada (CAD $)
  • United States (USD $)
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
  • © 2026, Old Town Spice Shop
  • Powered by Shopify

Join program to get rewards

Redeem your points for discounts

Use this discount code on your next order!

Reward expires on

Reward program

Give $5, Get $5

Create an account to claim discount.

Log in to redeem your points for rewards. Log in
'); printWindow.document.close(); // 5. Trigger the print dialog, then close the invisible window printWindow.focus(); setTimeout(function() { printWindow.print(); printWindow.close(); }, 250); }